Global EditionPremium world briefings with timeline, impact, and future-watch analysis.
A critical mauling: Brian Logan on comedy critics being portrayed as horrible snobs
Culture & SocietyThe Guardian14 Aug, 07:45 pmAtlasHour
Culture & Society

A critical mauling: Brian Logan on comedy critics being portrayed as horrible snobs

Two Edinburgh fringe shows feature savage send-ups of reviewers. Is this petty revenge or do they have a case? Our writer finds one ‘a hoot’ – and thinks the other let him off lightly No one ever built a statue to a critic, they say – but plenty of art gets made about them. There was Wild Bore at the Traverse a few Edinburgh fringes back, an eye-catching performance-art attack on the notion of critical authority. There was Tom Stoppard’s The Real Inspector Hound, Sheridan’s The Critic, and the 70s horror movie (later a play) Theatre of Blood, in which critics are subjected to gruesome murder at the hands of a deranged thesp. And while we’re talking unspeakable gore, one feature of Sarah Kane’s queasy play Cleansed, currently enjoying a revival, is that (in a wanton act of literary vengeance) its sadistic torturer antagonist is named after a theatre critic, Jack Tinker, who’d panned Kane’s work. Runts of the reviewing litter though we are, there’s even a sub-genre of art about comedy critics. The comic Russell Kane wrote a novel about one who was unable to laugh. Ex-critic Charlotte Runcie wrote another about a journo giving a woman a one-star review for her standup, then sleeping with her...

Source-linkedAtlasHour DeskThe Guardian14 Aug, 07:45 pm

What happened

Two Edinburgh fringe shows feature savage send-ups of reviewers.

Why it matters

AtlasHour context: this story may affect public policy, global affairs, business confidence, technology direction, energy security, or civic life.

Global context

The story is being tracked through Global Markets.

Who is affected

Global Markets

What to watch next

Readers should watch official responses, local reaction, source updates, and whether the story changes the next decision cycle.

Read the original source
Why It Matters

The consequence layer

AtlasHour context: this story may affect public policy, global affairs, business confidence, technology direction, energy security, or civic life.

Watch Next

What To Watch Next

Key Facts

Three facts to keep in view

1Source

The Guardian

1 min readRead time

Designed for a concise world-news brief.

1Context tags

Used for editorial story mapping and source context.

Read Next

Related Stories

AtlasHour updates articles as new verified information becomes available. Corrections and source context can be sent to the newsroom.